| 2016 | 14 | Ballots | 2017 | 13 | Ballots | 2018 | 12 | Ballots | 2019 | 10 | Ballots | 2020 | 6 | Ballots | ||||
| Player | Votes | % | Player | Votes | % | Player | Votes | % | Player | Votes | % | Player | Votes | % | ||||
| Mariano Rivera | 13 | 93% | Randy Johnson | 12 | 92% | Tim Hudson | 10 | 83% | Johan Santana | 8 | 80% | Bobby Abreau | 4 | 67% | ||||
| Roy Halladay | 12 | 86% | Pedro Martinez | 9 | 69% | David Ortiz | 9 | 75% | Pedro Martinez | 8 | 80% | Chipper Jones | 4 | 67% | ||||
| Vladimir Guerrero | 11 | 79% | Tim Hudson | 8 | 62% | Derek Jeter | 9 | 75% | Chipper Jones | 6 | 60% | Ichiro Suzuki | 4 | 67% | ||||
| Roy Oswalt | 11 | 79% | Chipper Jones | 7 | 54% | Pedro Martinez | 8 | 67% | Bobby Abreau | 6 | 60% | Dan Haren | 4 | 67% | ||||
| Jim Thome | 9 | 64% | Derek Jeter | 7 | 54% | Johan Santana | 8 | 67% | Ken Griffey Jr | 6 | 60% | Joe Nathan | 4 | 67% | ||||
| Chipper Jones | 9 | 64% | Barry Bonds | 7 | 54% | Bobby Abreau | 6 | 50% | Jim Thome | 4 | 40% | Jim Thome | 3 | 50% | ||||
| Randy Johnson | 8 | 57% | Derrek Lee | 7 | 54% | Chipper Jones | 6 | 50% | Carlos Beltran | 4 | 40% | Carlos Beltran | 3 | 50% | ||||
| Derek Jeter | 8 | 57% | Jim Thome | 6 | 46% | Jim Thome | 5 | 42% | Trevor Hoffman | 3 | 30% | Adrian Beltre | 3 | 50% | ||||
| Barry Bonds | 8 | 57% | Bobby Abreau | 6 | 46% | Chris Carpenter | 3 | 25% | Derrek Lee | 3 | 30% | Alex Rodriguez | 2 | 33% | ||||
| Bobby Abreau | 7 | 50% | Ken Griffey Jr | 6 | 46% | Alex Rodriguez | 3 | 25% | Todd Helton | 3 | 30% | Barry Bonds | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Pedro Martinez | 6 | 43% | Johan Santana | 6 | 46% | Lance Berkman | 3 | 25% | Barry Zito | 2 | 20% | Chris Carpenter | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Ken Griffey Jr | 5 | 36% | Trevor Hoffman | 6 | 46% | Trevor Hoffman | 3 | 25% | Carlos Delgado | 2 | 20% | Carlos Delgado | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Lance Berkman | 4 | 29% | Lance Berkman | 4 | 31% | Derrek Lee | 2 | 17% | Manny Ramirez | 2 | 20% | Derrek Lee | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Manny Ramirez | 2 | 14% | Manny Ramirez | 4 | 31% | Billy Wagner | 2 | 17% | Nomar Garciaparra | 2 | 20% | Barry Zito | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Derrek Lee | 2 | 14% | Chris Carpenter | 4 | 31% | Juan Pierre | 2 | 17% | Barry Bonds | 2 | 20% | Manny Ramirez | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Chris Carpenter | 2 | 14% | Frank Thomas | 3 | 23% | Greg Maddux | 2 | 17% | Alex Rodriguez | 2 | 20% | David Wright | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Carlos Delgado | 2 | 14% | Todd Helton | 2 | 15% | Carlos Delgado | 1 | 8% | Mike Piazza | 1 | 10% | Jake Peavy | 1 | 17% | ||||
| Todd Helton | 1 | 7% | Nomar Garciaparra | 2 | 15% | Todd Helton | 1 | 8% | Chris Carpenter | 1 | 10% | |||||||
| Nomar Garciaparra | 1 | 7% | Greg Maddux | 2 | 15% | Barry Zito | 1 | 8% | Billy Wagner | 1 | 10% | |||||||
| Mike Piazza (write in) | 1 | 7% | Billy Wagner | 2 | 15% | Dan Haren | 1 | 8% | Juan Pierre | 1 | 10% | |||||||
| Jorge Posada(write in) | 1 | 7% | Dan Haren | 2 | 15% | Ken Griffey Jr | 1 | 8% | Jonathon Papelbon | 1 | 10% | |||||||
| Jeff Bagwell | 1 | 7% | Carlos Delgado | 1 | 8% | Jorge Posada | 1 | 8% | Lance Berkman | 1 | 10% | |||||||
| Jason Giambi | 1 | 7% | Jorge Posada | 1 | 8% | Barry Bonds | 1 | 8% | ||||||||||
| Johan Santana | 1 | 7% | Jason Giambi | 1 | 8% | Jason Isringhausen | 1 | 8% | ||||||||||
| Greg Maddux | 1 | 7% | Gary Sheffield | 1 | 8% | |||||||||||||
| Curt Schilling | 1 | 7% | Juan Pierre | 1 | 8% | |||||||||||||
| 2021 | 15 | Ballots | 2022 | 12 | Ballots | 2023 | 11 | Ballots | ||||||||||
| Player | Votes | % | Player | Votes | % | Player | Votes | % | ||||||||||
| Chipper Jones | 13 | 87% | Joe Nathan | 12 | 100% | Bobby Abreau | 9 | 82% | ||||||||||
| Ichiro Suzuki | 12 | 80% | Adrien Beltre | 12 | 100% | Jim Thome | 7 | 63% | ||||||||||
| Joe Nathan | 8 | 53% | Alex Rodriguez | 8 | 67% | Francisco Rodriguez | 6 | 55% | ||||||||||
| Bobby Abreau | 7 | 47% | Bobby Abreau | 7 | 58% | Carlos Beltran | 6 | 55% | ||||||||||
| Adrien Beltre | 6 | 40% | Dan Haren | 7 | 58% | Joe Mauer | 6 | 55% | ||||||||||
| Carlos Beltran | 6 | 40% | Joe Mauer | 7 | 58% | CC Sabathia | 5 | 45% | ||||||||||
| Joe Mauer | 6 | 40% | Carlos Beltran | 6 | 50% | Chris Carpenter | 5 | 45% | ||||||||||
| Alex Rodriguez | 6 | 40% | Jim Thome | 6 | 50% | Dan Haren | 5 | 45% | ||||||||||
| Jim Thome | 5 | 33% | Barry Bonds | 5 | 42% | Barry Bonds | 4 | 36% | ||||||||||
| Francisco Rodriguez | 5 | 33% | Chris Carpenter | 4 | 33% | Barry Zito | 4 | 36% | ||||||||||
| Dan Haren | 5 | 33% | Barry Zito | 4 | 33% | Alex Rodriguez | 4 | 36% | ||||||||||
| Todd Helton | 4 | 27% | Todd Helton | 4 | 33% | Hanley Ramirez | 3 | 27% | ||||||||||
| Carlos Delgado | 3 | 20% | Manny Ramirez | 4 | 33% | Derrek Lee | 3 | 27% | ||||||||||
| Barry Zito | 3 | 20% | CC Sabathia | 4 | 33% | Manny Ramirez | 3 | 27% | ||||||||||
| Derrek Lee | 3 | 20% | Derrek Lee | 2 | 17% | Jonathon Papelbon | 2 | 18% | ||||||||||
| Chris Carpenter | 3 | 20% | Hanley Ramirez | 2 | 17% | Todd Helton | 2 | 18% | ||||||||||
| Brad Lidge | 2 | 13% | Trevor Hoffman | 2 | 17% | Ryan Howard | 1 | 9% | ||||||||||
| Barry Bonds | 2 | 13% | Victor Martinez | 2 | 17% | Adrien Gonzalez | 1 | 9% | ||||||||||
| Hanley Ramirez | 1 | 7% | Francisco Rodriguez | 2 | 17% | Jason Giambi | 1 | 9% | ||||||||||
| Trevor Hoffman | 1 | 7% | Huston Street | 2 | 17% | Eric Gagne | 1 | 9% | ||||||||||
| CC Sabathia | 1 | 7% | Ryan Howard | 1 | 8% | Trevor Hoffman | 1 | 9% | ||||||||||
| Manny Ramirez | 1 | 7% | David Wright | 1 | 8% | |||||||||||||
| Jason Giambi | 1 | 7% | Jose Reyes | 1 | 8% | |||||||||||||
| Jason Isringhausen | 1 | 7% | Jonathon Papelbon | 1 | 8% | |||||||||||||
| Huston Street | 1 | 7% | ||||||||||||||||